Sidebar
wg:dynamo:accuracy_results
Insulated boundary case
| Code | Resolution | $E_{kin}$ | $E_{mag}$ | $T$ | $U_{\phi}$ | $B_{\theta}$ | $\omega$ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Suggested solution | 30.773 | 626.41 | 0.37338 | -7.6250 | -4.9289 | -3.1017 | |
| UCSC | 42.4 | 30.684 | 626.002 | 0.37366 | -7.6155 | -4.8871 | -3.0857 |
| H2000 | 66.04 | 30.774 | 626.41 | 0.37308 | -7.6178 | -4.9313 | -3.1015 |
| H2000 | 82.33 | 30.774 | 626.42 | 0.37343 | -7.6267 | -4.9283 | -3.1017 |
| SPMODEL | 39.3686 | 30.7681 | 626.356 | 0.373785 | -7.63999 | -4.93412 | -3.10066 |
| MAGIC | 20 | 30.989 | 660.895 | 0.364179 | -6.92434 | -5.13508 | -2.91776 |
| MAGIC | 26 | 30.7225 | 626.574 | 0.364957 | -7.3101 | -5.04949 | -2.92483 |
| MAGIC | 31 | 30.7697 | 626.409 | 0.373843 | -7.64128 | -4.93392 | -3.10116 |
| MAGIC | 41 | 30.7743 | 626.409 | 0.373416 | -7.62614 | -4.92877 | -3.10157 |
| MAGIC | 49 | 30.7743 | 626.41 | 0.37339 | -7.6253 | -4.92892 | -3.10167 |
| MAGIC | 32 | 30.4416 | 620.688 | 0.373061 | -7.64412 | -4.8762 | -3.07104 |
| MAGIC | 37 | 30.7752 | 626.415 | 0.373417 | -7.62643 | -4.92879 | -3.10182 |
| MAGIC | 41 | 30.7743 | 626.409 | 0.373416 | -7.62614 | -4.92877 | -3.10157 |
| MAGIC | 44 | 30.7741 | 626.404 | 0.373416 | -7.62614 | -4.92874 | -3.10154 |
| Calypso | 40.5 | 30.9842 | 632.585 | 0.373956 | -7.63109 | -4.92019 | -3.12568 |
| Calypso | 60.5 | 30.9394 | 630.91 | 0.373348 | -7.62113 | -4.95774 | -3.12064 |
| Calypso | 69.2 | 30.8475 | 628.31 | 0.373289 | -7.61863 | -4.94572 | -3.1098 |
| xShells | 44.42 | 30.9012 | 624.308 | 0.37504 | -7.7793 | -4.8884 | -3.10368 |
| xShells | 48 | 30.8064 | 612.907 | 0.37405 | -8.037 | -4.7836 | -3.08182 |
| xShells | 60.48 | 30.8613 | 626.538 | 0.37344 | -7.6719 | -4.9254 | -3.10863 |
| xShells | 77.56 | 30.812 | 626.659 | 0.37334 | -7.6373 | -4.9272 | -3.1052 |
| xShells | 99.43 | 30.7928 | 626.568 | 0.37344 | -7.6333 | -4.9279 | -3.10354 |
| xShells | 129.27 | 30.782 | 626.483 | 0.3734 | -7.6279 | -4.9289 | -3.10254 |
| xShells | 155.87 | 30.7786 | 626.452 | 0.3734 | -7.6267 | -4.9289 | -3.10222 |
| LSD | 32.3 | 30.6999 | 624.616 | 0.3708 | -7.6484 | -4.834 | -3.089 |
| LSD | 50.8 | 30.8476 | 627.568 | 0.3732 | -7.6274 | -4.9291 | -3.107 |
| LSD | 58.3 | 30.7729 | 626.188 | 0.3732 | -7.6407 | -4.916 | -3.1011 |
| LSD | 64.3 | 30.763 | 625.987 | 0.3726 | -7.6741 | -4.892 | -3.0997 |
| LSD | 69.4 | 30.7606 | 625.939 | 0.3729 | -7.6599 | -4.9025 | -3.1012 |
| LSD | 73.8 | 30.7595 | 625.912 | 0.3725 | -7.6609 | -4.8961 | -3.1008 |
| LSD | 96.3 | 30.7649 | 626.19 | 0.3732 | -7.6332 | -4.9206 | -3.1013 |
| ETH code | 127 | 30.774 | 626.39 | 0.37339 | -7.625 | -4.9288 | -3.1017 |
| ETH code | 81 | 30.774 | 626.4 | 0.37341 | -7.627 | -4.9281 | -3.1017 |
| ETH code | 41 | 30.635 | 623.67 | 0.37342 | -7.612 | -4.8703 | -3.0829 |
| MOSFFT | 30.739 | 626.26 | 0.359 | -7.636 | -4.911 | -3.113 | |
| FT-PSD | 34.76 | 30.616 | 622.49 | 0.37404 | -7.6175 | -4.8646 | -3.0875 |
| FT-PSD | 43.61 | 30.669 | 624.88 | 0.37392 | -7.5855 | -4.8742 | -3.0844 |
| FT-PSD | 49.85 | 30.675 | 625.06 | 0.37391 | -7.5848 | -4.8748 | -3.0847 |
| FT-PSD | 41.49 | 30.534 | 620.5 | 0.37347 | -7.6508 | -4.9105 | -3.099 |
| FT-PSD | 45.54 | 30.679 | 624.05 | 0.37328 | -7.6269 | -4.9247 | -3.0985 |
| FT-PSD | 51.99 | 30.751 | 625.78 | 0.3732 | -7.6178 | -4.9323 | -3.1005 |
| FT-PSD | 57.15 | 30.765 | 626.15 | 0.37319 | -7.6162 | -4.9339 | -3.1012 |
| Parody | 45.9786 | 30.596 | 616.28 | 0.3733 | -7.769 | -4.88 | -3.101 |
| Parody | 56.6964 | 30.748 | 624.25 | 0.3731 | -7.652 | -4.925 | -3.104 |
| Parody | 67.2211 | 30.767 | 625.71 | 0.3731 | -7.626 | -4.933 | -3.103 |
| Parody | 73.9864 | 30.77 | 626.02 | 0.373 | -7.62 | -4.934 | -3.102 |
| SBS | 51.8538 | 30.7246 | 625.702 | 0.3727 | -7.6724 | -4.8971 | -3.1046 |
| SFEMaNS | 203.9 | 30.629 | 627.729 | 0.37362 | -7.5915 | -4.89809 | |
| GeoFEM | 79.25 | 31.238 | 635.5 | 0.371288 | -7.38088 | -4.99522 | -2.97504 |
| GeoFEM | 125.8 | 31.404 | 632.98 | 0.373514 | -7.58122 | -4.99065 | -3.12018 |
Relative error for kinetic energy $E_{kin}$ from suggested solution
Relative error for magnetic energy $E_{mag}$ from suggested solution
Relative error for temperature $T$ from suggested solution
Relative error for $\phi$-component of velocity $u_{\phi}$ from suggested solution
Relative error for $\theta$-component of velocity $B_{\theta}$ from suggested solution
Relative error for drift frequency $\omega$ from suggested solution
Pseudo vacuum boundary case
| Code | Resolution | $E_{kin}$ | $E_{mag}$ | $T$ | $U_{\phi}$ | $B_{\theta}$ | $\omega$ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| UCSC | 37.8 | 40.649 | 219.57 | 0.42534 | -11.636 | 1.4082 | 0.7488 |
| Calypso | 52.8 | 40.8683 | 218.965 | 0.426041 | -11.6148 | 1.39693 | 0.743255 |
| H2000 | 66.04 | 40.678 | 219.39 | 0.42593 | -11.635 | 1.4039 | 0.74975 |
| H2000 | 82.33 | 40.679 | 219.39 | 0.42595 | -11.636 | 1.4042 | 0.74978 |
| SPMODEL | 29.0739 | 40.753 | 218.769 | 0.425931 | -11.6256 | 1.39489 | 0.752479 |
| MOSFFT | 37.9 | 40.8055 | 218.783 | 0.4261 | -11.6158 | 1.39441 | 0.75312 |
| ETH code | 52.9 | 40.6809 | 219.405 | 0.4259 | -11.6334 | 1.40446 | 0.7502 |
| ETH code | 60.5 | 40.6798 | 219.405 | 0.4259 | -11.6341 | 1.40502 | 0.74978 |
| ETH code | 70.2 | 40.6806 | 219.401 | 0.426 | -11.6359 | 1.40417 | 0.7498 |
| ETH code | 80.6 | 40.6798 | 219.395 | 0.4259 | -11.6357 | 1.40431 | 0.74978 |
| ETH code | 126 | 40.6787 | 219.395 | 0.4259 | -11.6357 | 1.40431 | 0.74976 |
| MOSFFT | 40.646 | 219.59 | 0.402 | -11.486 | 1.403 | 0.7483 | |
| SFEMaNS | 203.9 | 40.542 | 220.78 | 0.42553 | -11.6559 | 1.4164 | |
| FT-PSD | 41.3225 | 40.099 | 223.21 | 0.4253 | -11.615 | 1.4414 | 0.799 |
| FT-PSD | 51.7064 | 40.302 | 222.35 | 0.4256 | -11.645 | 1.4304 | 0.7639 |
| FT-PSD | 59.1891 | 40.476 | 220.99 | 0.4257 | -11.641 | 1.4177 | 0.7543 |
Relative error for kinetic energy $E_{kin}$ from suggested solution
Relative error for magnetic energy $E_{mag}$ from suggested solution
Relative error for temperature $T$ from suggested solution
Relative error for $\phi$-component of velocity $u_{\phi}$ from suggested solution
Relative error for $\theta$-component of velocity $B_{\theta}$ from suggested solution
Relative error for drift frequency $\omega$ from suggested solution
wg/dynamo/accuracy_results.txt · Last modified: 2018/11/28 21:52 (external edit)
Except where otherwise noted, content on this wiki is licensed under the following license: CC Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported
